In Islamic teachings, navigating a moral conflict between telling the truth and potentially causing harm to another person involves careful consideration of the values of honesty, harm prevention, and the broader ethical implications of one’s actions. Here are the key factors that should guide decision-making in such situations:Prioritisation of Harm Prevention (Avoiding Harm – “La Darar wa La Dirar”): A fundamental principle in Islam is to avoid causing harm to oneself or others. If speaking the truth directly leads to harm, it might be permissible, or even necessary, to withhold certain information or present it in a way that minimizes harm without resorting to outright lies.Intentions (Niyyah): The intention behind your actions is crucial in Islam. If the intention is to protect someone from harm and not to deceive or manipulate for personal gain, Islamically, this intention may justify withholding certain information or finding a gentle way to present the truth.Situational Context and Greater Good (Maslahah): The concept of Maslahah emphasizes the pursuit of the common good and welfare of the community. When truth-telling may result in greater harm or conflict, balancing the act by considering what serves the greater good and prevents broader damage becomes essential.Permissibility of White Lies (Tawriyah): In situations of genuine necessity, Islam allows what is known as tawriyah, a form of indirect speech that does not involve lying but carefully crafts statements to avoid falsehood while not disclosing full details that could cause harm.Consulting Scholars and Seeking Guidance (Shura): In complex moral dilemmas, seeking advice from knowledgeable and trusted Islamic scholars can provide valuable guidance. This aligns with the Islamic principle of consultation (shura) in decision-making.Weighing Potential Consequences: Consider the short-term and long-term consequences of both telling the truth and withholding it. Sometimes, revealing a painful truth might ultimately lead to healing and resolution, whereas hiding it might cause more profound issues later.Duties and Trusts (Amanah): If you are in a position of trust, such as a counsellor, doctor, or friend who has promised confidentiality, fulfilling that trust becomes paramount unless withholding the truth causes significant harm, such as in life-threatening situations.Maintaining Good Relations (Silat ar-Rahim): Preserving relationships and maintaining harmony, especially within families and communities, is highly valued. If truth-telling would cause unnecessary discord, Islam encourages finding the most peaceful approach possible.
Rabia Adnan Answered question November 7, 2024
Sufyan Kori Answered question August 28, 2024